Jump to content

Dr. Pepper

Members
  • Content count

    11,065
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Dr. Pepper

  • Rank
    I'm a nasty woman

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Not Telling

Recent Profile Visitors

9,461 profile views
  1. Dr. Pepper

    Upcoming TV Series of 2018/2019 - Your most anticipated shows

    Did y'all actually get it on Netflix over there? They have released season one on Amazon Prime, but nothing beyond that. It's like no one involved with the show really cares if it succeeds. Everyone I recommended the show to is uninterested because there is no way to catch up before the new season starts.
  2. Dr. Pepper

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    I'll repeat, I'm not accusing you of not enjoying the show. I couldn't care less if you do. I took me a long time and two tries to get into it. My surprise is that you didn't like the mash up feel even though the books are apparently a mash up.
  3. Dr. Pepper

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    Ok, so the books were very white. What I want to know is why that poster has such a reaction to the show being inclusive. It doesn't appear the fundamentally change the story, so who careas? The gut check feeling doesn't deny the fact that the books were reimaginings of other stories, which was the problem you claimed to have with the show. It wasn't that you had a gut check at the changes, it's that you remarked on the idea that things were 'stolen' from other stories, yet this was the fundamental concept of the books.
  4. Dr. Pepper

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    I was reading an interview with Les Grossman and he points out that his books are a purposeful reimagining of other tales, a grey area, slipping painfully close to fan fiction. Knowing this, I'm rather surprised that book readers are complaining that the show is sticking with the spirit of the books by doing that very same thing. https://www.vox.com/culture/2018/1/18/16883082/magicians-lev-grossman-syfy-narnia-harry-potter-remix
  5. Dr. Pepper

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    I liked it. I think it's hilarious that the show is very purposefully reusing some fantasy cliches, and they're so meta about it. Is there a certain reason why the people of Fillory need to be white? Are they a white supremacist group in the books? Because if there is no particular reason for them to be white, then keeping jobs from a diverse population just because seems like a pretty white supremacist view on things.
  6. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    So your conclusion is that maybe they didn't go off script, but maybe their reputation for going off script is why Drummer sends them. Yes, they have a gun ship, but so does she. She has access to dozens. We were with her in real time while she used those ships and void cities during a war with Laconia. Sorry, but things were going to change after Holden's stunt. Drummer was aware of it. Unless you think she was also wrong. Again, the only reason we don't see the fall out from it is because Laconia showed up.
  7. Dr. Pepper

    Mental Wellbeing Thread

    I have that weird feeling where I'm concerned that I'm not sad or depressed and because I'm not I think something must be wrong. My triad relationship ended really abruptly. The mess and the filth became too much, it was making me physically and mentally ill. I decided to move out. I take things literally and can be nothing other than honest and have a hard time figuring out when people aren't being literal or don't want honesty, so when they asked me to be honest about the reasons why, I told them simply that they were too mess and filthy for me but still felt our relationship could continue if we lived in separate housing. It really was horrible, if I explained how filthy then you'd all understand. But they didn't like that and took offense and we exchanged mean words and I thought fine, whatever I was starting to hate that location anyway. Plus it was getting really cold and I honestly hate the cold. So I started driving and driving and driving and ended up back to where I started years and years ago and I feel really ok with it. More than ok, I feel like I never left and a certain sense of peace that I'm where I want to be. Haven't felt any missing of my friends/girlfriends. Haven't answered them or felt a desire to reach out in return. I feel content with this decision. But also wondering if maybe I'm numb because I had several big moves last year. I get really uncomfortable when I feel content. It doesn't feel normal.
  8. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    The stability argument comes into it when you consider that the characters were static. When there was a bunch of instability, it was understable why the Roci crew was used despite their unpredictable nature. Many times they were the only option, or the only best option. But if they've been static for 30 years when the three major powers have enjoyed a steady alliance, then their continued service seems ludicrous. The TU is building massive cities and war ships. They have a full component of diplomats and other governmental type workers. They don't need the Roci crew, they don't need that unpredictability. The use of her at the start of the series is what makes the static nature of the crew stupid and lazy. Literally nothing has changed with them. It's like they were frozen in time, with a few minutes of Alex getting married and having a kid, which didn't seem to affect him in any way. Bobbie mentions the kid more than Alex does and only to highlight how much she and Alex are besties. Any stories they mention tend to be ones that happened 30+ years ago. They were a crew stuck in times gone past and somehow the major players are still hiring them. No way. Kills the plausibility of the book. I hope this series is almost done. I'm thankfully not giving any money to it, but I'm stuck in that space where I've devoted enough time that I just want to see how it ends.
  9. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    Sorry, I guess I missed those three decade long periods of stability in those other books. You'll have to point them out to me. Maybe also try to point out how during those periods of instability the Roci crew weren't uniquely situated to be offered the job (in those situations where they didn't force their way in). Keep in mind that they had a very specialized ship and the use of such ship was something that helped the belt be on more even keel during those periods of instability. This isn't the case after 30+ years of no wars and exponential growth. The Roci is now an aging ship, the crew an aging one that doesn't follow orders. It's stupid as fuck that Drummer is calling on this gun ship with a known problematic crew when there were obviously other options for such a serious job.
  10. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    Oh, come on, let's not be dishonest here. "They did everything just fine except for all those times they didn't." That's true about anything and allows you to handwave all the stupid shit away. The fact is that almost all of these characters ended up together precisely because they frequently broke the rules and didn't follow orders. I think Alex might be the only exception in the group. The reasons that Holden and co were able to get away with it in the previous books is because things were in serious and constant flux and they were often the only ones with all of the info, the skills, or the willingness. The were contracted largely because there was no other choice and nearly everyone who worked with them complained about how they did things. These books start at the tail end of 30 years of stability. A crew whose basic characterisation includes breaking the rules isn't going going to stay employed long with the major powers unless they undergo major changes and the book goes through some (albeit lazy) effort to claim they didn't. They either underwent major changes or they didn't.
  11. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    Yeah, good point. There are plenty of people who would need to hire Holden. It's more that I'm baffled heads of governments or the TU would do it. Only the authors made the point of telling us that nothing had changed with our group, other than a stray marriage and kid and some creaking bones. Even while in Freehold is pointed out that Bobbie is used to adjusting to going off script. She can read Holden so well, they've been doing it so long, blah blah blah. It's why alternative POVs would have improved things in the book. I assume the authors were too lazy to bother.
  12. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    That would explain how they might have high profile and important jobs in the years immediately after we last saw them. Might even carry them for a decade. But 30 years? No way. They can only ignore the parameters of the job or completely alter relationships between governing bodies so much before that celebrity status no longer holds weight. Which is why alternative POVs would have been helpful. They could have clarified reasons why the Roci crew's star keeps shining so bright even though they can't seem to do what they're hired to do. Holden's decision causes more than just a headache. It fundamentally alters the nature of the Transport Union and in turn changes the TU's relationship with governing bodies they interact with. Signatory planets didn't agree to terms with a government, they agreed to terms with a trade union. If the TU is now a government, they are basically Laconia and they'll have to do certain things to annex a bunch of worlds who maybe don't want to be annexed. If it remains a union, then Holden's actions show that first violation of the union contract incurs pretty minor consequence. What if ten worlds do what Freehold did? Twenty? One hundred? What number need flout the rules before the minor consequence then becomes too burdensome to the TU? I think it's pretty valid to point out that Holden ignoring the parameters of the job he was given could have easily resulted in a lot of disruption in the system. The only reason we don't see any of the fall out from Holden's decision is because Laconia showed up.
  13. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    Agree with everything @Kalbear wrote, but in addition, the bolded just makes it all the more absurd. Why on earth are people still hiring the Rocinante? They are unreliable and they don't follow orders. They are so much the same that their actions are still resulting in potential systemic change. Their actions with Freehold could have set off a system wide war, trade wars at the least, if Laconia hadn't shown up. Everything about the crew is the same as when we left them 30 years ago, even their going all cowboy on missions. This is why we really needed other POVs to tell us what the rest of the known universe thought of the Roci crew. The time jump just doesn't work when it comes to the Roci POV.
  14. Dr. Pepper

    Persepolis Rising (Book 7 of the Expanse) - SPOILERS

    This was such a slog to get through. The time jump was a good idea but completely unbelievable. It probably would have worked better if there had been other POV's who had lived in the same world where Holden and co were minor celebs but who were regular people. Someone else's POV might have given the sense that there was a passage of time. Even the planet we saw was a fledgeling one. Our favorite characters were all the same as they were when we last left them, just with some creaky bones. How can 30 years go by without a single thing changing about a person? It was as though the authors understood they needed a time jump to give Laconia the chance to build the resources needed to actually take control of the known universe with just a handful of ships but they were too busy or lazy to actually think through what that time jump would mean for the rest of the cast. Probably the only thing I mildly enjoyed about this book is how for a moment we were all a bit like Bobbie where Duarte's plan seems like an elegant one, a plan we dream about. One nation under peace, where can I sign up. But then, as Mormont points out, a bit of thought on it and you can't ignore that Duarte is a horrific person. Even if we ignore all that he did in the past to murder bullions, this book kicks off with notes about how he uses his population for human experimentation.
  15. Dr. Pepper

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    There's also the warrior, which is Kady. In the trailer when the Cock went through the list, they had Alice as the Torture Artist. Although there was no Poppy in the trailer so maybe that's a reveal for a later day and she'll fit in there somehow. The Dean was also shown a lot on the trailer, though with no official purpose for the Quest.
×