Jump to content

The Ned's Little Girl

Members
  • Content Count

    1,446
  • Joined

5 Followers

About The Ned's Little Girl

  • Rank
    With rings on her fingers and bells on her toes
  • Birthday August 20

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Array
  • Location
    Array

Recent Profile Visitors

2,641 profile views
  1. A friend of mine had all her calligrapher friends draw henna tattoos on her head. She looked fabulous!
  2. Sending good vibes your way, @sweetsunray ! Although chemo is a difficult experience even at its easiest, I'm glad you and your doctors are taking all the precautions. Looking forward to your new posts when you're all better!
  3. This neatly illustrates the difference between Westerosi culture and our own. By Ned's and Catelyn's standards (especially Catelyn) they were doing right by their daughter in betrothing her to the highest-status consort in the land. That is simply their reality. So the question becomes: which is more at fault, a badly fucked-up culture or the people who have been trained since birth to abide by its (badly fucked-up) dictates? It's a rare person who can mentally and emotionally distance themselves from their upbringing, their training and inculcated beliefs to recognize the shortcomings and defects of the society they are immersed in. Most especially when, exactly like Ned and Catelyn, they are at the pinnacle of that very society, where they are the recipients of all its benefits and at the same time insulated from most (if not all) of its defects. As such, they and others of their class have zero impetus to think critically about their notions of reality causing harm. To rephrase Sinclair Lewis' famous saying for a Westeros context, it is difficult to get people to fully understand the negative aspects of their own culture when their status and power depends upon their not understanding it.
  4. He did that to make Sansa complicit, to implicate her in the deed.
  5. I personally would be very disappointed and irritated if the story ended up in the exact same place where it began, with a monarch (any monarch) on the Iron Throne in Kings Landing, lording it over 7 kingdoms. Especially if it's implied that the whole sturm and drang will just start up again and replay itself, because history is circular blah blah blah. That would be cheap, lazy writing in my opinion. As far as where/how the story will end up, as long as it is in a place different from where/how it began, I'll be satisfied.
  6. Which is why I didn't say that either.
  7. Much of the "textual support" is wishful thinking. Like this: Dany lived in a house on the grounds of the Sealord's palace. Arya spends her time in a working-class district on the waterfront. The two girls have very different experiences of the same city. Or, as if she currently isn't who she thinks she ought to be: a Targaryen princess living in splendor at the royal court, someone who would never be married off into a band of savages like the Dothraki. Instead she's spent the majority of her life as a homeless vagrant dependent on charity; that's not the person she thinks she is, or ought to be.
  8. Exactly. The show is about "bad things happen to people". That's why the shocking scenes are contrived and jarring. The books are about "why bad things happen to people". That's why the shocking scenes are organic and momentous.
  9. Why are you assuming I "don't get this"? In fact, I do "get this". I was pointing out that "this" makes no sense. And Mel also went on and on about the leeches, but somehow hasn't yet managed to put Balon Greyjoy away. Hmmm. Wouldn't someone want some more assurances, or some more proof that it will do any good at all, before they burn their child and sole heir?
  10. Okay, I'll bite. How is this act of burning his daughter necessary for his destiny? What was his reason? What was he trying to accomplish? What is the likelihood (if any) that his goals (if any) by this action will (or can) come to pass? Was there discussion of this act: weighing of options, calculations of outcomes?
  11. LOL, what North? Is there even a "North" to rally? They seem pretty thin on the ground thus far. Naw, Stannis won't burn Sansa. He'll burn Selyse and then forcibly marry Sansa, because that just can't happen to her enough, can it? Besides, he needs an heir now, doesn't he? *shudder* I apologize. I should head back to the Rant & Rave thread.
  12. OMG! Those poor people trying to stay hydrated as they march through piles and piles of snow!! Whatever shall they do, amidst all those snowdrifts, to get some life-giving water! How can they keep walking with literally millions of snowflakes falling into their faces and melting on their skin... and their lips.... and their tongues.....!!!!! Finally! Some common sense. Thank you.
  13. Soooooo not what I was saying. I can "believe the show is true to the book" or not, but still D&D have no business confirming one way or the other. Both they and GRRM have been saying for a long time now that, although they will arrive in the same place at the end, the show and the book will be taking greatly different roads to get there. The only logical purpose in handling it that way is exactly so the show doesn't spoil the books, so viewers won't know which events are in the books and which are D&D's own version. And hey! Thanks for the advice on staying out of spoiler threads! Not that I was asking for any. I am a grownup, after all, and perfectly capable of deciding for myself what to read or not.
  14. I'd like to say one thing about the show spoiling the books. I'm sure it's been said already, but I think it bears reiterating. Everybody understands that the show is going beyond published material. Everybody. That is not the issue. The issue is: D&D confirming that a particular thing will happen in a yet-unpublished book. It doesn't matter what the thing is, they should not spoil it. If questioned, they should say, "To know if {an event} happens in the next book, you'll have to read the next book. Until you do read the next book, we will not confirm or deny anything." We should not know for certain what is going to happen in unpublished material. We should be left guessing (and theorizing). Discretion is the better part of valor. I guess D&D don't have any valor.
×
×
  • Create New...