Rhaenys_Targaryen Posted October 20, 2013 Share Posted October 20, 2013 GRRM already stated that he was not very good with dominant genes, alleles and so on. I go for the simplest explanation possible - children inherit their looks from their parents, with an old ancestor popping from time to time in someone's hair or nose. I understand that GRRM hasn't plotted out the gene pool of all the Targs :) But I just wanted to point out that it's possible for Aerys and Rhaella to have silver hair, even if Jaehaerys hadn't married a women with Valyrian colouring. I study Medical Biology at the university, so the biologist inside of me was screaming, and I couldn't stop typing for a while :) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anath Posted October 20, 2013 Share Posted October 20, 2013 I understand that GRRM hasn't plotted out the gene pool of all the Targs :) But I just wanted to point out that it's possible for Aerys and Rhaella to have silver hair, even if Jaehaerys hadn't married a women with Valyrian colouring. I study Medical Biology at the university, so the biologist inside of me was screaming, and I couldn't stop typing for a while :) And I was quite interested to read it all. I thought it was a shame GRRM couldn't use something like that but then, I can't either, so I am really not the one to talk. My knowledge of genetics is limited to, "Mom and Dad are blue-eyed and kiddo has those lovely dark eyes? Well, who IS the father?" Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
chrisdaw Posted October 20, 2013 Share Posted October 20, 2013 Are you fishing for a Sansa Parallel? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lord Thaeglei of Frostpyre Posted May 9, 2014 Share Posted May 9, 2014 Hmmm.. Let's see.. Here is a definitive list of consorts to Targaryen kings and princes.. King Aegon I Targaryen-m-Princess Visenya TargaryenPrincess Rhaenys Targaryen --- King Aenys I Targaryen-m-Lady Alyssa Velaryon --- King Maegor I Targaryen-m-Unknown Targaryen PrincessLady Jeyne WesterlingLady Alys HarrowayLady Tyanna of Pentos --- King Jaehaerys I Targaryen-m-Princess Alysanne Targaryen --- Prince Aemon Targaryen-m-Lady Jocelyn Baratheon --- Prince Baelon Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- King Viserys I Targaryen-m-Unknown Lady ArrynLady Alicent Hightower --- King Aegon II Targaryen-m-Princess Helaena Targaryen --- King Aegon III Targaryen-m-Princess Jaehaera TargaryenLady Daenaera Velaryon --- King Baelor I Targaryen-m-Princess Daena Targaryen --- King Viserys II Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- King Aegon IV Targaryen-m-Princess Naerys Targaryen --- King Daeron II Targaryen-m-Princess Myriah Martell --- Prince Baelor Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- King Aerys I Targaryen-m-Princess Aelinor Targaryen --- Prince Rhaegel Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- King Maekar I Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- Prince Daeron Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- Prince Aerion Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- King Aegon V Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- Prince Duncan Targaryen-m-Jenny of OldstonesLady Olenna Redwyne (possible betrothal) --- King Jaehaerys II Targaryen-m-Unknown wife --- King Aerys II Targaryen-m-Princess Rhaella Targaryen --- Prince Rhaegar Targaryen-m-Princess Elia MartellLady Lyanna Stark (?) So, the confirmed Targaryen-blooded queens and consorts were: Princess Visenya TargaryenPrincess Rhaenys TargaryenMaegor I's unknown Targaryen sister-wifePrincess Alysanne TargaryenPrincess Helaena TargaryenPrincess Jaehaera TargaryenPrincess Daena TargaryenPrincess Naerys TargaryenPrincess Aelinor TargaryenPrincess Rhaella Targaryen On the other hand, the non-Targaryen queens and consorts were: Lady Alyssa VelaryonLady Jeyne WesterlingLady Alys HarrowayLady Tyanna of PentosLady Jocelyn BaratheonUnknown Lady ArrynLady Alicent HightowerLady Daenaera VelaryonPrincess Myriah MartellLady Olenna Redwyne (?)Jenny of OldstonesPrincess Elia MartellLady Lyanna Stark (?) I find it interesting that that first non-Valyrian (Targaryen and Velaryon) Queen Consort of the Seven Kings was a Westerling of The Crag.. This might be a glimpse of prestige the Westerling background was back then.. I know other might say that Maegor I had many wives and his marriage to a Westerling is no big deal.. if i remember correctly, Maegor I did practice polygamy BUT the only women he was married to at the same time were Alys of House Harroway of Harrenhal (scion of a family who were lords of the greatest castle in Westeros) and Tyanna of Pentos (probably a Valyrian herself).. It was never said that Jeyne had any rival queens in her tenure as Maegor's wife.. I think, Jeyne Westerling as not just "a" queen when she was Maegor's wife.. She, like Maegor's Targaryen sister-wife "the" queen of the Seven Kingdoms.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rhaenys_Targaryen Posted May 9, 2014 Share Posted May 9, 2014 Has it actually been confirmed that Tyanna of Pentos (especially her) and Alys Harroway were Maegor's wives? Because in the preview page of the World Book, that wasn't stated. Maegor very possibly had been married to the eldest daughter of Aenys, to secure his claim over Jaehaerys more (I vaguely recall Maegor having had 2 Targaryen wives at the least). Jocelyn Baratheon would have Targaryen blood, due to Orys having been Aegon's halfbrother. And with the information that Valaena Velaryon had a Targaryen mother, I wouldn't be surprised if Daenaera Velaryon (wife of Aegon III) and Alyssa Velaryon (wife of Aenys I) also had Targaryen blood. The unknown Arryn Queen is known to have had Targaryen blood (because Rhaenyra had more Targaryen blood than her brother Aegon, and the only difference in parentage was their mothers.) Elia had dragonsblood through Daenerys Targaryen, sister of Daeron II. Making the list of consorts and possible consorts without Targaryen blood smaller and smaller. :) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bael's Bastard Posted May 9, 2014 Share Posted May 9, 2014 Since there were supposedly approximately 12 non-Targaryen queens of Westeros during the reign of the Targaryen dynasty, not counting the multiple wives of Maegor the Cruel, we should try to find out which kings had non-Targaryen queens before we finally find out ;-).Let's start at the end:1. Prince Rhaegar: Elia of Dorne, and perhaps Lyanna Stark2. Jaehaerys II married for love, so most likely no Targaryen mother for Aerys and Rhaella.3. Mystery son of Egg: Also married for love - most likely no Targaryen bride.4. Duncan Targaryen: Jenny of Oldstones, gave up his claim to the Iron Throne5. Aegon V Targaryen: Married for love, so likely no Egg for Rhae and Daella6. Daeron II married Myriah Martell7. Aegon III had a Velaryon as his second queen8. Viserys I had two non-Targaryen wives, an Arryn and a Hightower, although the Arryn queen seems to have had Targaryen ancestors.9. Maegor had multiple non-Targaryen wives, but I guess he had also one or two Targaryen wives.Other candidates would be:1. Viserys' II wife/queen, the mother of Aegon IV, Naerys, and the Dragonknight. Apparently there were not much/no Targaryen wives left after the Dance. My guess he was also married to Velaryon (his children all had Valyrian features).2. Daeron's I queen also seems to have been not a Targaryen: Daena was betrothed to Baelor, and Daeron had no elder sisters. His only other female Targaryen cousin was Naerys, and she was married to Aegon IV.3. Baelor Breakspear's wife: Valarr does not look as much a Targaryen as Aerion, Aemon, and Egg.Any idea who I missed?12 non-Targ queens according to what/who? Also, Baelor Breakspear and Egg's unnamed son and Duncan and Rhaegar were never kings and their wives never queens, so perhaps you can elaborate on what this 12 non-Targ queens claim is based on, so we can try to pin diwn what was actually said and how it might actually apply.Non-Targaryen wives we know of,1. Aenys' Velaryon queen2. Maegor's Westerling queen3. Maegor's Harroway queen4. Maegor's Pentos queen5. Viserys I's Arryn queen6. Viserys I's Hightower queen7. Aegon III's Velaryon queen8. Daeron II's Martell queenKings whose wives' identities we know nothing about,1. Daeron I's queen2. Viserys II's queen3. Maekar's queen4. Aegon V's queen5. Jaehaerys II's queenI don't know that it can be deduced who had the rest of the non-Targ wives beside those of the first eight I listed. Some of those who we know had Targ queens could have also had non-Targ queens at some point.Marrying for love doesn't necessarily mean a non-Targaryen, especially when political betrothals/marriages are mostly going to be to seal alliances with other houses, not Targaryens.Marrying for love may mean marrying one non-Targ when they were betrothed to another non-Targ, marrying a non-Targ when they were betrothed to a Targ, or marrying a Targ when they were betrothed to a non-Targ. We don't know enough. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bael's Bastard Posted May 9, 2014 Share Posted May 9, 2014 Has it actually been confirmed that Tyanna of Pentos (especially her) and Alys Harroway were Maegor's wives? Because in the preview page of the World Book, that wasn't stated. Maegor very possibly had been married to the eldest daughter of Aenys, to secure his claim over Jaehaerys more (I vaguely recall Maegor having had 2 Targaryen wives at the least). Jocelyn Baratheon would have Targaryen blood, due to Orys having been Aegon's halfbrother. And with the information that Valaena Velaryon had a Targaryen mother, I wouldn't be surprised if Daenaera Velaryon (wife of Aegon III) and Alyssa Velaryon (wife of Aenys I) also had Targaryen blood. The unknown Arryn Queen is known to have had Targaryen blood (because Rhaenyra had more Targaryen blood than her brother Aegon, and the only difference in parentage was their mothers.) Elia had dragonsblood through Daenerys Targaryen, sister of Daeron II. Making the list of consorts and possible consorts without Targaryen blood smaller and smaller. :)Targ ancestry does not make one a Targ. They are two different things. For instance, if Orys was a bastard son of Aerion (which is rumor, not confirmed), he still wasn't a Targ. And Aemon and Rhaegar were never kings, and their wives never queens. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TheCrannogDweller Posted May 9, 2014 Share Posted May 9, 2014 To put it in a generational context and a direct line of descendancy (reds are branches that died off, blacks are the ones through which the royal line was continued): 1. King Aegon I - Rhaenys/Visenya Targaryen2. King Aenys I - Alyssa Velaryon => King Maegor - various wives3. King Jaehaerys I - Alysanne Targaryen4. Unclear5. King Viserys I - Lady Arryn/ Alicent Hightower6. Queen Rhaenyra - Laenor Velaryon/ Daemon Targaryen <=> King Aegon II - Helaena Targaryen7. King Aegon III - Jaehaera Targaryen/ Daenaera Velaryon => King Viserys II - unknown wife8. King Daeron I - unknown wife => King Baelor I - Daena Targaryen => King Aegon IV - Naerys Targaryen9. King Daeron II - Myriah Martell10. King Aerys I - Aelinor Targaryen => King Maekar - unknown wife11. King Aegon V - unknown wife12. King Jaehaerys II - unknown wife13. King Aerys II - Rhaella Targaryen Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rhaenys_Targaryen Posted May 9, 2014 Share Posted May 9, 2014 Non-Targaryen wives we know of,1. Aenys' Velaryon queen2. Maegor's Westerling queen3. Maegor's Harroway queen4. Maegor's Pentos queen 5. Viserys I's Arryn queen6. Viserys I's Hightower queen7. Aegon III's Velaryon queen8. Daeron II's Martell queenAgain, where are Alys Harroway and Tyanna of Pentos, especially Tyanna, stated as Maegors confirmed wives? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bael's Bastard Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 If they are not confirmed forget them. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
assjfjgjsgjljljglgjfjsduar Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 The Rogue Prince story should confirm the ID of Viserys I's Arryn wife. Worth noting that even though she wasn't a Targaryen, she had Targaryen ancestry. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lady Blizzardborn Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 Targ ancestry does not make one a Targ. They are two different things. For instance, if Orys was a bastard son of Aerion (which is rumor, not confirmed), he still wasn't a Targ. And Aemon and Rhaegar were never kings, and their wives never queens. Wait a minute, Aerion from the Dunk and Egg stories? Is there more than one Orys, because I only know of the Orys Baratheon who started the line and he was born way, way before Aerion was. We don't really know for sure that he was a Targaryen. Rumored to be the bastard son of Aegon I's father, but sometimes rumors are wrong. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rhaenys_Targaryen Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 The Rogue Prince story should confirm the ID of Viserys I's Arryn wife. Worth noting that even though she wasn't a Targaryen, she had Targaryen ancestry. Indeed. My guess is that either the mother of the Arryn queen, or the grandmother was a Targaryen. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mrs.Grumpy Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 Maegor's wives;Jeyne WesterlingAlys Harrowaypossibly Tyanna of Pentosmaybe Rhaena Targaryen (rider of Dreamfyre) (she is a Targ but still xd) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rhaenys_Targaryen Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 Maegor's wives;Jeyne WesterlingAlys Harrowaypossibly Tyanna of Pentosmaybe Rhaena Targaryen (rider of Dreamfyre) (she is a Targ but still xd)I recall having heard from a reading that Maegor had at least 2 Targaryens wives. Definitly his half sister, and very possibly also Aenys' eldest child and daughter, possibly to strengthen Maegors claim to the throne.Tyanna of Pentos seems to have been a healer to me, since she appears in the preciew when Maegor had been poisoned and was being healed. Alys most likely was GIS wife, but we don't have any confirmation on that yet Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lord Varys Posted May 10, 2014 Author Share Posted May 10, 2014 I seem to recall that Ran mentioned that there were about 12 non-Targaryen brides/queens in the family tree when I started this thing. That's nothing I came up with. But Rhaenys is of course right - it does seem that most of the queens not bearing the Targaryen name where Targaryen descendants through the female branch. This is confirmed for Viserys' Arryn queen in TPatQ - Beesbury claiming that Rhaenyra had more Targaryen blood than Alicent's children - and is most likely also true for all of the Velaryon wives/queens. We already know that Laenor and Laena Velaryon had Targaryen mothers, and it's thus very likely that Daenaera Velaryon and Alyssa Velaryon had also Targaryen blood themselves. We don't know anything about lesser branches of House Targaryen at the time of the Conquest - Aenar moved with all his family to Dragonstone, and there may have been some distant cousins still around at that time, male or female. Lord Daemon Velaryon and Alyssa Velaryon could be descended from a Velaryon marrying a Targaryen girl from a lesser branch. If Aenys was indeed only born in 7 AC, it's very unlikely that he was married to a daughter of Daemon Velaryon, who died during the Conquest. Daenaera could be the granddaughter or great-granddaughter from one of Jaehaerys' daughters. It's very likely that Rhaenys Targaryen - the (only?) child of Prince Aemon Targaryen - was married to a consort who also descended from a Targaryen. And we should also keep in mind that Rhaenys most likely would have become Queen Regnant if Jaehaerys had died early, and Aemon had followed his father on the Iron Throne... This possibility must have come up when the match between Rhaenys and Corlys was arranged. We don't know anything about Corlys' siblings, but he may have had some, and Daenaera could descend from one of them. The whole Addam/Alyn thing from TPatQ most likely reflects Corlys' wishes that a child from his own line should follow him as Lord of Driftmark, not some nephew or grandnephew. This would strengthen the possibility that Addam and Alyn are indeed supposed to be the children of Laenor, rather than Corlys' own. Prince Aemon being married to Jocelyn Baratheon also seems to suggests that one of Aenys' sisters was married to Orys Baratheon's son. Orys was Aegon's best friend and confidant. Surely one of Aegon's sisters was married to his best friend's son, the heir of Storm's End. Jocelyn may have been one of the younger daughters (or a granddaughter) from that union. As to Maegor's wives: It's confirmed that his first wife was one of Aenys' sisters. It has also been mentioned that he did not have only one Targaryen wife, but at least another. The best candidate for that is Aenys' eldest child, a daughter, who was also considered a candidate for the succession while Aegon was still alive (and it was clear that Aenys would follow his father on the Iron Throne). By marrying his niece Maegor would have strengthened his own claim to the Iron Throne. This niece could have been the Rhaena Targaryen who once rode Dreamfyre, but his has yet to be confirmed. We don't know how many children Aenys had - it could have been three (Rhaena, Alysanne, Jaehaerys), it could have been more. His other wives are simply no known up to this point. But I guess we should not really call them 'queens' - especially not the Westerling wife - because they seem to have been nothing but Maegor's desperate attempts to father any (trueborn) children. Alys Harroway could be a candidate for a bride. The fact that she presents herself to the public with Maegor and Tyanna could indicate that she was a woman Maegor truly loved - at least for a time. Tyanna could have married him eventually, but it seems to me that excerpt indicated that she came to court with Visenya, who fired Maegor's healers and maesters and had Tyanna see to him. In guess Visenya had officially retired at that time and spent her time on Dragonstone, possibly with young Jaehaerys and Alysanne. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mrs.Grumpy Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 rogue princeRhaena is mentioned as Maegor's "black bride". Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AnnieStace Posted May 10, 2014 Share Posted May 10, 2014 Are we allowed to bring spoilers for "The Rogue Prince" here? The story has some information relevant to this thread, but I couldn't find the rules about discussing the leaked info. Edited for spoilers. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lord Thaeglei of Frostpyre Posted June 13, 2014 Share Posted June 13, 2014 After the Stark family tree was disclosed, i had this crackpot theory that the wife of King Daeron I the Young Dragon could have been, well ------------- Lady Sansa Stark.. Well, seeing that King Aegon III ordered his second son Baelor to be the once to continue the practice of incentous marriage to his own sister despite his reluctance.. So meaning, a non-Targaryen blood lady was most probably chosen for the young Daeron.. I'm thinking that Lady Sansa was the grandaughter of Cregan Stark, Lord of Winterfell who supported Queen Rhaenyra Targaryen's claim.. Lady Sansa's mother was Lady Jeyne Manderly and we all know that the Manderlys were also one the staunchest supporters of Queen Rhaenyra's claim.. I think it would be wise for Aegon III to marry his eldest son and heir to the daughter of 2 of his mothers most loyal supporters, both very powerful houses to booth.. Aside from the Velaryons and Arryns, the Starks are the best possible match for Aegon III's heir.. The Martells are out of the picture since Dorne was still an independent kingdom back then (note: it was even Daeron I who conquered Dorne), the Baratheons betrayed Rhaenyra's cause and allowed Prince Lucerys Velaryon, Rhaenyra's son and Aegon III's brother to be killed and the Lannisters fought for Aegon II in the last civil war.. Therefore i think a Stark-Manderly daughter is the best choice, of king's blood and stayed loyal to Rhaenyra and Aegon III's cause during the Dance of the Dragons.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RumHam Posted June 13, 2014 Share Posted June 13, 2014 rogue prince Rhaena is mentioned as Maegor's "black bitch". That...doesn't sound right. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.