Jump to content

The Weirwoods Eyes

  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About The Weirwoods Eyes

  • Rank
    Must think of something Witty to say here.
  • Birthday 05/19/1981

Profile Information

  • Gender
  • Location
    North Yorkshire

Recent Profile Visitors

4,385 profile views
  1. what are you basing this on? I didn't notice anything in F&B that gave us her colours?
  2. The best theory I have ever seen as to how Tommen dies is the 7 deadly oils theory. Thought up by a very clever lady on another forum. She proposes that Tyene Sand who has been tasked with travelling to KL dressed as a Septa and gaining the trust of the High Septon, will use her knowledge of poisons to adulterate the 7 sacred oils which are used in the anointing ceremony of a new King, a ceremony Cersei has mentioned several times which she wishes the High Septon to carry out. When the High Septon anoints Tommen both he and Tommen will perish. Ridding us of an arse on the IT, making way fro Myrcella and Trystane, and the High Sparrow too. So I don't think fAegon will have to do the deed. Though I do think that Jon Connington will kill Myrcella as he has expressed a desire to do so in revenge for Rhaenys's murder, his silver princes daughter. And that he will do so via the tunnels used by Blood & Cheese in TP&TQ which Varys has knowledge of. To smother her in her sleep with a silk pillow as Tywin said ought to have been the previous princesses fate.
  3. The Weirwoods Eyes

    The were-wood hypothesis

    I'm absolutely certain that the connection is intended.
  4. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Why did Jon lock Ghost up?

    Plot devise as The Sleeper said. GRRM needed Jon to get stabbed and he realises that Ghost would be a pretty persuasive preventive; the same way he had to get rid of the girls direwolves in order for their stories to go in the directions he wanted for them, so he invented a plot devise to have Ghost unable to defend Jon when his brothers came for him. Sometimes that is all there is to an event. Plot device.
  5. The Weirwoods Eyes

    The were-wood hypothesis

    There are loads of real world myth, fairy tale, and folk lore connections in ASOIAF and yes I'm afraid there are a fair amount of things which play on the English language which must get lost in translations. Which is a shame for non English speakers. I personally think the were in weirwood refers only to the seers who are living underneath the tree's. As Bran is now. I believe though that there has been some discussion in the past regarding the tree's and some sort of sentence. I want to tag @Seams as I think at the back of my murky brain they were involved in that thread. But even if that is a trick of my memory you'll get some interesting discussion regarding words and word play.
  6. The Weirwoods Eyes

    The were-wood hypothesis

    Native English speaker. Yes Weir/Were is an old word for man and is where we get werewolf etc from so weirwood means man tree and the tree's literally have men; people, in them as we learn in the books via Bran meeting Bloodraven and the CotF.
  7. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Who will Sansa marry?

    Except that when he hears that she has been married to Tyrion he flies into a rage, kills a bunch of people and ends up sobbing and talking about where the heart is begging her sister to end his pain. Remember when Loras flew into a frenzy and killed his brothers after Renly's death.....
  8. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Who will Sansa marry?

    During the scene at the Blackwater Sandor does not try to rape Sansa. And using hyperbole doesn't strengthen your argument. What he does is go to her room; after he has decided to abandon the Lannisters following the incident at the gate with Tyrion attempting to force him back into the fires, where finding her absent he lays down on her bed to wait for her. Upon her return she lays on her bed and finds him there, he reaches out for her and he threatens to kill her if she screams. But the thing is we already know that she won't. Because the author has taken the time to set up their relationship and on several occasions prior he surprises her in a similar way. In fact he does so at their first meeting; when she thinks he is her father, anyway the point is the reader knows there is no threat to Sansa and she immediately calms. They begin to speak and he tells her he is lost. She realises he was sleeping in her bed and wonders what he wanted. That's a big part of the dialogue here, her youth means she isn't aware fully of the physical relationship between man and woman. She knows the mechanics as she lets us know after her wedding. But she has not understanding yet of desire. Which again is part of her story, it is about her sexual awakening. But right here in this scene she is not awake to that. So she misses much of his innuendo. They discuss Tyrion, Sandor wants him burnt in retaliation for him trying to force him back into the fires. He says he is going, then and says he is going away from the fires; ie away from all that has hurt him, he says North somewhere, which implies towards her home. So to leave behind his pain he will go to her lands, he's about to ask her to go with him. Sansa says the gates are closed and he says not to me, she asks why he came to her room, and he replies that she promised him a song. She doesn't understand this obviously and says let me go you are scaring me. He says everything scares you and asks her to look at him. This whole exchange is about facing your fears, and the fact she is too young yet to be with him. he says look at me, and she takes in all the detail of his ruined face and then he declares that no one would ever hurt her again if she were to go with him, he pulls her closer and this is when she thinks he will kiss her. A kiss she later realises she wanted. This becomes the basis for her fantasies, so much so that she convinces herself he did kiss her and she centres that kiss in her sexual awakening. Referring back to it repeatedly and imagining scandalising her peers. This is when he mistakes her readying herself to be kissed for her still being unable to look upon his face. And he pulls his dagger. Now you can act all outraged about that if you like. But that doesn't change the symbolism GRRM has used here and elsewhere in the book with daggers and desire. Nor the fact it is a common writing device. She can't recall the love song that she had sort of promised him earlier, of Jonquil and Florian. But she instead sings him the Mothers song, this coming after she prayed for the Mother to gentle his heart. After the song he tosses his cloak to her and leaves. She then climbs under the cloak and that in itself is symbolic. Twice he has given her his cloak. Cloaks are an integral part pf westerosi weddings and three is the magic number! The third time he gives her his cloak will be their wedding in my opinion. The cloak is white and spattered with blood. This is representative of the wedding sheet, displayed after a marriage to shwo the brides virginity. Then their are bells ringing out just like in our world where wedding bells are rung, and then she places the cloak in her cedar chest with her summer silks. The chest represents a Hope Chest an American tradition made from cedar and heavily advertised and popularised in GRRM's youth. The idea being that you place items that you hope to use in your married life in it in preparation. Placing it with her summer silks represents hope for the future just as Summer's name does. GRRM has used a hope chest and explained what it is in another B&TB inspired story of his. The Skin Trade. So We know for certain he knows what they are and what he was symbolising in this scene. But no where in that scene did Sandor try to rape her. ETA: an interesting fact is this. Sansa prayed for Sandor's heart to be gentled, She then sang him the Mothers song a song all about finding a better way, of stilling the rage and the violence, and Sandor is now on the QI being ministered to by the Elder Brother who says The Hound is no more. The hound of course being his fierce persona the one who is full of rage and violence. He's not fully tamed as we see via Stranger's refusal to be gelded. But what this whole thing does imply is that he is no longer consumed by his anger and hatred for his brother. His heart has been gentled just as Sansa asked for.
  9. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Barristan's vigil for Set Hugh of the Vale

    I think it does indeed tell us the depth of Barristan's character and that is important. Every thing that we learn about him during the story paints a picture and that picture is an honest, honorable, and principled man. So it means that when he starts talking we know he's not BS'ing and can be taken seriously as a source. As to Ser Hugh, I think he simply fell victim to Gregor Clegane. Both LF and Varys take advantage of Ser Hugh's timely death. And he serves as a nice little red herring in the who killed Jon Arryn story.
  10. The Weirwoods Eyes

    What is the true religion in Westros ?!

    There is no real evidence that any gods other than the Old Gods in the form of greenseers in the weirwood net actually exist.
  11. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Who will Sansa marry?

    The reason why threads about who Sansa will end up with always revert to SanSan is because that is the direction her romantic interest lies and no matter how much people dislike it it is what is in the actual story. When you look at the story; the one between them, it clearly follows a romance format. You can break it down to the formula of a mills & Boon or any other romance novel or rom com. And that is something lots of readers don't like. They don't want to accept that GRRM likes romance stories. Tough shit he does and he is very open about that. He has talked about how he is a romantic, he likes romance, ASOIAF is a romance, He finds it irritating how maligned the romance genre is. etc etc. He's woven the classic format into Sansa's arc and he has done it very cleverly. Yes he's used B&TB and he has done so repeatedly throughout his career. He loves that story.
  12. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Who will Sansa marry?

    I'm not demanding anything. I have explained why it is an unpleasant way to talk about women. And I have explained the way it has become common parlance for the special kind of sad twat you find reading blogs about picking up "females" by negging and then has creeped into usage by the general population. I have not demanded anything. You might not think it is rude to remove a woman's humanity by using the generic term female when referring to women in a non institutionalised setting. But lots of women do, pointing that out doesn't make me the PC police. Just a woman who doesn't like being busted down to the same category as livestock and who has patiently explained why several times now. I mentioned it on page bloody 4! and the person who I mentioned it to made it clear they didn't care about the negative connotations and would continue to refer to human women as females. And anyone who cares to look will note I didn't say a word. I dropped it. No demands where made. You brought it back up. I again and in greater detail carefully explained how it has been adopted to dehumanise and degrade women in exactly the same way as bitches; in fact in some circles it is simply used as short hand for bitch. A way of swearing when you would not otherwise get away with it female dog = bitch. And for gods sake yes, get back on topic!
  13. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Was Tywin Lannister a villain?

    You seem to think I don't understand the story. You are wrong. I'm not arguing what you think I am arguing. I have been talking about the emotions which motivate Tywins actions. Tywin is a villain, that doesn't mean everything he does is pure evil, that isn't how the books work. Very few characters are purely evil. In fact even some of those who seem it can be looked at and examined and you can see why they behave as they do. But the crux of this discussion has not been about if Tywin was a villain but rather what motives his actions. And it has been like hitting my head against a brick wall!
  14. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Was Tywin Lannister a villain?

    Thank you. And yes I totally agree re Tywin.
  15. The Weirwoods Eyes

    Was Tywin Lannister a villain?

    I didn't assume you are American, I said We are not all American. I guessed the man in question was/is American the name is vaguely familiar. It's not an automatic understanding when you give a name I don't know, a whole decade(not even the one it occurred in!) And a country. That what you are referring to is bombing of Japan. Not to mention that it's just not part of our curriculum to any extent. We learn about the second world war sure but the names of the Americans involved in the bombing of Japan never came up. What was he like the man who made it? The pilot who dropped it? I wouldn't have a clue. Maybe if I'd done world history? But I didn't I did social and economic, Ask me about the levellers or the horse drawn hoe or the match girl strikes, the Peterloo Massacre. I can tell you all about those.